Tag Archive: Pia Toscano

The Best American Idol Performances of All Time

This list was never about me. When I started it back in 2014, I wanted to put together a comprehensive list of the 30 best performances in American Idol history but I wanted… Continue reading

The Dude Abides: With the American Idol Top 7 singing American Classics, here’s what Jax, Joey and Tyanna should sing

For the second week in a row, American Idol teases an incredibly vague theme. Wonder if the Idols had any trouble picking out an “American Classic?” American Classic could mean anything and with… Continue reading

American Idol Top 30 Performances of All Time: Recapping Nos. 30-11

I started this list back in June, then got sidetracked with work and life. Don’t be mistaken – the list is complete. Just have to bang out the recaps. If you’ve been to… Continue reading

American Idol Top 30 Performances of All Time: No. 25, Pia Toscano, “I’ll Stand By You”

The judging in American Idol’s first season post-Simon Cowell was an unmitigated disaster. Simon was so beloved as a judge because he didn’t bullshit anyone. He wasn’t mean for the sake of being… Continue reading

  • Dudes Review Idol

  • Tweet, tweet, Son

  • Advertisements